It’s hard to channel the American political mindset of 2018, but back then it was not at all clear that Republican primary elections were about to become Donald Trump impersonator contests.
It was genuinely weird that the three Republicans running for U.S. Senate in Indiana that year were all trying to present as Trumpian. Here’s how USA TODAY’s Maureen Groppe set the table:
Mirror, mirror on the wall, who’s the Trumpiest of them all?
That’s the dominant question in the GOP Senate primary as U.S. Reps. Todd Rokita and Luke Messer and former state legislator Mike Braun compete for the chance to take on Democratic Sen. Joe Donnelly this fall.
All three are closely aligning themselves with President Trump — but in different ways — while attacking the Trump credentials of their opponents.
That reads somewhat cliche today, but it really was a novel storyline!
If that 2018 Senate primary was an early, somewhat comic example of the Republican Party’s lurch toward MAGA, then it’s only fitting that now-Gov. Mike Braun’s 2028 reelection campaign is testing how Republicans can distance themselves from Trump.
Braun launched his campaign this week. He previewed his second-term vision for me during an hourlong conversation at the governor’s residence. The former blue-shirt-wearing Trump stan now wants his reelection bid focused on policies to reduce prices.
The problem is, people have memories. Braun led Trump’s unpopular — and nearly devastating for Republicans — early redistricting push, which failed last year in Indiana.
Now, Braun is struggling to reconcile his Trump ties and low approval rating with this new post-Trump version of himself. I wrote for IndyStar:
Braun acknowledges Indiana’s redistricting attempt “didn’t make sense” in light of the elections. Yet he doesn’t explain why he led President Donald Trump’s failed push to paint more Indiana congressional districts red. He also doesn’t answer when I ask whether he regrets it.
This is Braun’s central conflict. He’s running for reelection from a position of extraordinary weakness for a Republican Indiana governor. A recent Free Press Indiana/Bellwether Research poll found only 38% of likely voters approve of Braun’s job performance (Braun is “definitely” skeptical of that number, he tells me). Republican Attorney General Todd Rokita is nipping at his heels.
Braun accepts the “wake-up call” for Republicans, as he describes it. He has a harder time seeing his own role in causing it.
Meanwhile, Attorney General Todd Rokita, one of Braun’s foes in that 2018 battle of the Trumpiest, appears interested in taking on Braun one more time. If we get a rematch, it looks like Braun will switch characters to play the Affordability Guy while Rokita takes his Trump gimmick for one last ride, like an aging sports team whose championship window is closing.
Braun sidestepped some of my questions — particularly on redistricting — but sounded confident when sizing up Rokita.
“He and I are going to be aligned on most of the issues that don’t get into some fringe ideology,” Braun told me.
I wrote two columns stemming from my Braun interview:
I discussed those columns on the Rob Kendall Show, which you can watch above. I also wrote about Indianapolis Public Schools’ latest unserious round of school closings:
Voters don’t know what they want elected officials to do
I give Braun credit for trying to interpret the midterm election results and acting on his conclusions. But voters are not exactly giving elected officials a prescription for next steps.
National Review’s Charles C. W. Cooke sums up the conundrum for shell-shocked Republicans, as well as newly empowered Democrats thinking they have a mandate to order their favorite preexisting lib policy ideas off the menu:
The voters are a bit stupid, no? I don’t say this because they voted against the Republican Party — or, more accurately, against Donald Trump. I say it because they’re shallow and fickle. Through both the last year of Biden’s presidency and the past two years of Trump’s, they have convinced themselves that the economy is much worse than it is. (Some polling shows that people are more unhappy with the economy now than they were in 2009 — that’s ridiculous.) And they have no idea what the government can and can’t do about it. In the space of just two years, we’ve been through two massive shifts in preferences — first toward the Republicans in 2024, then toward the Democrats in 2026. Why? Because the electorate seems to think that it can vote its way to immediate gratification.
It can’t. Especially when the problem is the voters themselves. Look at any issue polling and you’ll find that the public wants it all ways. It wants taxes to go down but spending to go up. It wants to increase Social Security outlays while reducing Social Security contributions. It wants inflation to go away but for interest rates to return to the historically abnormal rates that were caused by the financial crash. It likes the idea of bringing manufacturing back to the United States but reacts violently to tariffs and is busy trying to ban data centers. It wants more money spent on schools but for its property taxes to be slashed. And, above all else, it wants deflation — not for the price of a sandwich to stop rising but for it to go back to what it cost in 2019. Of course our politics is chaotic. It’s being driven by a bunch of drunks.
Conflicting preferences don’t make voters stupid, but Cooke’s analysis points to the political hazard of promising affordability without trade-offs. Any agenda that gave voters all of that would be extremely hard, extremely unpopular or both.
Americans just told politicians to act — but not to do this, that or especially that. Good luck!


